Is Miyamoto losing touch with “gamers”?

Over the past twenty years, Shigeru Miyamoto has changed the video game industry like no other. He is Nintendo. Without him the gaming industry would be completely different today. There would be no Nintendo, and who knows what games would be like.
The games he made early on in his career have become staples in the industry. Donkey Kong, Mario, Legend of Zelda, F-Zero, Super Mario Kart, Star Fox, and Kirby are all Miyamoto games. More than likely he is the reason you game today. He is what every game developer dreams to be.
After saying all this a person cannot help but think, “Where are his AAA titles today?” Over the past decade Miyamoto has continued to recycle his old franchises. This is fine considering that his old franchises are amazing, but where is the innovation for hardcore gamers? His new franchises have all been casual Wii titles. Wii Music and Wii Fit are the two most recent games than Miyamoto has had a serious hand in. Both games are completely different than what he has done over the past twenty years.
Now it’s completely understandable that as he gets older that he doesn’t want to continue to create massive new hardcore games. Miyamoto has never been the type of developer to create very “hardcore” games, but he always made games that appealed to hardcore gamers. His main philosophy is to make fun games and be innovative. Over the past five years he has been innovative, but has he continued to make fun games? Can Wii Fit and Wii Music even be considered games? Miyamoto is like that fun college buddy who used to be a blast, but is now married and has a mini-van.
Gamers would think that Miyamoto would be proud of his work on the Nintendo 64 and the Gamecube, but oddly enough he feels quite the opposite. He has repeatedly said that he felt “unhappy” and “uninspired” during those years. Now with the Wii he feels that the console has helped “rejuvenate” his career.
The N64 and Gamecube has a library of classic Miyamoto titles. If anything he should be proud of those years. Yeah he wasn’t winning the console race, but at least he was putting out quality products tht people enjoyed.
Maybe he has changed and wants to develop experiences for a younger/more casual audience. As long as he continues to work on his older franchises then gamers will continue to be happy, but wouldn’t it be nice if he created one last epic expierence for the old school Nintendo fans? Either way he has created his legacy in the industry and we should be forever grateful. Though if you want something new from him then you better get used to Nintendogs, Wii Titles, and the recycling of Nintendo classics.


